top of page
Fire Island, New York beach boardwalk

Exceptional Homes.
Luxury Stays.

FIVE STAR HOMES. SIX-STAR SERVICE.

Thoughtfully Managed Properties. Unforgettable Experiences.

Shore Thing Icons homepage with icons alongside text of: Curated Luxury Homes, Impeccable Cleanliness, Airbnb Superhost, Concierge Level Service, VRBO Premier Hosts, Trusted Local Expertise, 24/7 Guest Support

Explore Our Collection

​

DISTINCT HOMES. UNMATCHED EXPERIENCES.

From expansive homes accommodating up to 24 guests to intimate oceanfront retreats for 8, Shore Thing's curated collection is crafted for unforgettable experiences. With more than 40 five-star reviews across our portfolio, you can book with confidence, knowing every stay is thoughtfully prepared and designed to create lasting memories.

The picturesque view looking to the beach from the top roof with two oversized Adirondack chairs

GATSBY'S

OCEAN BAY PARK

FIRE ISLAND, NEW YORK

The ultimate large-group luxury retreat where every celebration deserves an extraordinary setting.

Sea La Vie 18.jpeg

SEA LA VIE

OCEAN BEACH

FIRE ISLAND, NEW YORK

A private coastal retreat for larger groups, featuring an expansive deck just steps from the ocean and the heart of town.

Back Deck 4.png

DREAM VIEW

OCEAN BAY PARK

FIRE ISLAND, NEW YORK

Everything you come to Fire Island for, framed by an unforgettable oceanfront view.

Coming Soon Horizontal_.png

GOLDEN HOUR

​OCEAN BAY PARK

FIRE ISLAND, NEW YORK

Bird's eye view of Easy Breezy

EASY BREEZY

GULF OF MEXICO

DAUPHIN ISLAND, ALABAMA

State Outlines - Alabama_edited.jpg

Perfectly positioned between the Gulf and the Bay, offering the perfect balance of relaxation, adventure, and island charm. 

Coming Soon Horizontal_.png

What Our Guests Are Saying

Sara

September 2025

Stayed with kids

Stayed at Gatsby's

Had a large group of friends and family for an extended weekend. We were lucky with perfect beach weather so the proximity to the beach was great, and the house came with all the chairs and cabanas to accommodate our group.

Brian and Cassie went above and beyond to get us a giant lobster pot for a cookout we were having and checked in every day to make sure we had towels, got us anything we thought we needed and generally make sure we were good.

House is very nice - just as pictured, with lots of room. We enjoyed sunsets in the giant chairs and evening dips in the pool and hot tubs. Cannot recommend enough if you are looking to celebrate a special occasion.

Our guests were blown away by the place. Would absolutely return.

Gastbys 3.png

Have You Stayed With Us?

Whether you've stayed at a Shore Thing property a year ago or a week ago, we'd love to hear what you thought.

Shore Thing owner, Cassie, and dog, Red

Contact Us

Get in touch with us at Shore Thing Property Management for bookings, inquiries, or any other assistance. We're here to make your beach getaway an exceptional one.

bottom of page